Skip to main content
  1. Home
  2. Smart Home
  3. News

Long Island couple sues over copyrighted mansion design

By

courtroom ai attorney
Creative Commons
Just how much are your dreams worth? If they manifest themselves in the form of a mansion, quite a bit, it would seem. After a neighbor copied the design of one Long Island couple’s dream home in the Nassau County village of Lawrence, Seth and Rivka Fortgang filed a lawsuit to protect their design. The house itself is valued at $1.48 million, and Rivka Fortgang copyrighted the architectural plans (because apparently, she knew something like this would happen).

BUILD YOUR OWN: Long Island couple sues neighbors for copying their mansion https://t.co/KW59ZTXO5G pic.twitter.com/pevWEYnfnJ

— New York Daily News (@NYDailyNews) July 7, 2016

According to the lawsuit, which was filed in Long Island Federal Court, the neighbors actually requested the copyrighted plans from the Village of Lawrence Building Department. After hearing of this development and noticing the construction of an eerily similar house taking form in nearby Cedarhurst, the Fortgangs reached out to their lawyers.

Recommended Videos

But the neighbors, Daniella and Ari Schwartz, insist they are doing nothing wrong. Their lawyer, Daniel Schloss, has noted in court documents that there is nothing so unique about the Fortgangs’ home that it would be protected by the Copyright Act.

“We note that the exterior façade of the Fortgang residence consists of several windows, rather generic gables, and entry way doors,” Schloss said. “However in the interests of professional courtesy, our clients have agreed to temporarily postpone construction of the present design … pending certain changes and amendments to its exterior façade elements,” he added.

But if you think the story ends there, think again. According to the lawsuit, Rivka Fortgang, an exterior and interior designer in her own right, has suffered “substantial damage to her reputation and her business in the upscale Five Towns community as a result of the copying,” the New York Daily News reports.

Neither the Fortgangs nor their lawyers have responded to requests for comment.

So watch out, prospective home builders. If you’re not a proponent of the notion that imitation is the sincerest form of flattery, you may want to look into copyrighting your own designs sometime soon.

Topics
Lulu Chang
Lulu Chang
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Fascinated by the effects of technology on human interaction, Lulu believes that if her parents can use your new app…
Nest Doorbell vs. Ring Battery Doorbell Plus: which is the better video doorbell?
The Ring Battery Doorbell Plus installed outside a front door.

Ring and Nest are responsible for some of the best video doorbells available. With easy-to-use smartphone apps, simple installation processes, and the ability to customize your motion alerts, the Ring Battery Doorbell Plus and Nest Doorbell have quickly established themselves as two of the best video doorbells money can buy.

But what exactly is the difference between these two popular gadgets? And which is better for your smart home?

Read more
The best Apple HomeKit devices for 2023
A person unlocking the Aqara U100 smart lock with their phone.

While not as widespread as Google Home or Amazon Alexa, Apple HomeKit remains one of the most popular smart home ecosystems of 2023. The software plays well with iOS devices, and several other gadgets such as smart lights, smart locks, thermostats, and cameras can be controlled using the fancy technology. If you’re looking to build your smart home around Apple’s ecosystem, here are the best HomeKit devices available today.
Locks

HomeKit doesn’t have the largest selection of smart locks, but that doesn’t really matter when you have something as well-rounded as the Aqara Smart Lock U100. Not only does it offer full HomeKit support, but you’ll even gain access to Apple home keys -- allowing you to unlock your door with your iPhone or Apple Watch. There’s also the standard keypad for entering a passcode, along with a fingerprint sensor that can store several dozen fingerprints (so your whole family can enter the home without worrying about forgetting their password or smartphone).

Read more
Secure your home with Ring Floodlight Cam Plus and save $80
Ring Floodlight Camera placed on a wall outside.

Best Buy has one of the best security camera deals at the moment with $80 off the Ring Floodlight Cam Plus Outdoor Wired Surveillance Camera. Usually priced at $200, it's down to $120 for a limited time only so if you're fast enough, you'll save a lot of cash. If you're looking to secure your home, keep reading while we tell you all about the advantages this security camera offers.

Why you should buy the Ring Floodlight Cam Plus
Considered to be one of the best floodlight cameras for someone seeking a hard-wired solution, the Ring Floodlight Cam Plus Outdoor Wired Surveillance Camera is a highly effective home security measure.

Read more