Skip to main content

Mario wins big at the Game Critics Awards: Best of E3 2017

Nintendo and Ubisoft win big at Game Critics Awards

mario game critics awards best e3 2017 mariorabbids
Nintendo’s famous portly plumber dominated E3 discussion this year, and that has paid off at the Game Critics Awards. Split between Super Mario Odyssey and Mario + Rabbids: Kingdom Battle, Mario took home five awards this year, including “best of show” for Super Mario Odyssey.

The Game Critics Awards: Best of E3 2017  is an annual list of the most exciting games showcased during the E3 games expo. Like other awards, they run the gamut from action titles, to RPGs, from online multiplayer to top indies. The list is created and the results tallied from votes from 40 global media publications and for games to be considered, they must have been shown at E3 with at least five minutes of hands-on game time available.

Recommended Videos

We were impressed with Mario + Rabbids Kingdom Battle during our first look at it, so we aren’t surprised that the game managed to make such an impression with voters.

Like Mario + Rabbids, Shadow of War was nominated for four awards, though it came home empty handed. Wolfenstein II: The New Colossus also received four nominations, winning for “best action game.” Destiny 2 managed to pick up the win for “best PC game,” even though its predecessor only released on consoles. Electronic Arts’ Star Wars Battlefront II also managed to take home the “best online multiplayer” award, beating out Call of Duty: WWII, Sea of Thieves, and Skull & Bones.

It was the big games from the big developers and big publishers which made the most impact with game critics this year, it seems. However, a few smaller games did make an appearance in the “best independent” category. There, we saw Ashen, Bloodstained: Ritual of the Night, Donut County, Laser League, and The Artful Escape of Francis Vendetti all competing for the top spot. The Artful Escape ultimately took home the win.

Other wins at the Game Critics Awards included FIFA 18 for “best sports game,” Ni No Kuni II: Revenant Kingdom for “best role-playing game,” and Dragon Ball FighterZ for “best fighting game.” Arc System Works’ fighter surprised just about everyone with its crisp combat and authentic anime visuals, stealing much of the spotlight from Capcom’s Marvel vs. Capcom: Infinite.

Noticeable absences from all categories include games like Cuphead, Anthem, Beyond Good and Evil 2, Kingdom Hearts 3, XCOM 2: War of the Chosen, and Xenoblade Chronicles 2, but all were disqualified for not having playable demos available to voting publications. The Xbox One X received a hardware award, but Microsoft’s games were otherwise absent from the winners’ list, as well. Sony received no wins, even though it had shown off a long list of games that included God of War and Days Gone — both took home awards in Digital Trends’ E3 awards.

Updated on 6-29-2017 by Gabe Gurwin: Added information on award winners.

Jon Martindale
Jon Martindale is the Evergreen Coordinator for Computing, overseeing a team of writers addressing all the latest how to…
Summer Game Fest returns just before E3 2023 next June
The official artwork confirming Summer Game Fest's return on June 8, 2023.

Geoff Keighley has confirmed when Summer Game Fest will return in June 2023. It will begin with a live kickoff show on June 8, 2023, placing Keighley's game announcement alternative less than a week before E3's grand (intended) 2023 return.
Unlike past years, Summer Game Fest Live Kickoff 2023 will feature a live audience, like Geoff Keighley's The Game Awards. It will take place in the YouTube Theater at Hollywood Park, with tickets going on sale in early 2023. It will still be livestreamed across platforms like YouTube and Twitch, though. It's currently unknown who's participating, how long Summer Game Fest will run afterward, or if it will feature a Summer Game Fest Play Days-like element for fans. Still, Keighley says all of that info will be revealed ahead of the event next year, teasing what people can expect. 
"In keeping with tradition, we'll have tons of exciting announcements from the developers that are pushing the games industry forward, and will once again highlight other publisher digital events, demos, and more surprises to be announced in the coming months," Keighley says in a press release. 
That June 8 start date, and the other Summer Game Fest events likely to follow, put Keighley's show just ahead of E3 2023. The ESA and ReedPop plan to bring E3 back between June 13 and June 16, 2023. With five days of lead time on E3, Summer Game Fest can coexist with the long-running gaming conference and encompass the plethora of publisher showcases that tend to precede E3.
Geoff Keighley made it clear that he wants Summer Game Fest and E3 to coexist for a while. "We've had extensive conversations with ReedPop about E3," he said in an interview with Epic Games Store. "I think it'll kind of fit together and flow kind of from what we're doing into what they're doing and stuff. E3, to me, is this kind of master brand that represents gaming news in June."
With the start date of Summer Game Fest confirmed, the coexistence of these two summer gaming events is a reality. Summer Game Fest returns on June 8, 2023.

Read more
The best video games of October 2022: Mario, Bayonetta, and more
An angry Wiggler ambushes the heroes from behind in Mario + Rabbids: Sparks of Hope.

After some odd summer months that were dominated by indie and AA games, the AAA part of the video game industry is finally back in the swing of things. October 2022 saw the release of the year's biggest games, and many of them didn't disappoint. From ambitious sequels to games taking bold risks with established franchises, this October was the most exciting month for gaming since March 2022. 
With so many fantastic games coming out, some of them might not be on your radar. That's why I've rounded up the eight best games from October 2022 that you need to check out before the end of the year. 
Mario + Rabbids: Sparks of Hope 
Mario + Rabbids Sparks of Hope: Story Trailer
Ubisoft finally released a sequel to 2017's surprise strategy game hit Mario + Rabbids: Kingdom Battle and innovated while doing it. This game drops the grid setup common in the tactics genre, giving players the option to run around with their characters each turn, jumping off allies and dashing into enemies along the way. This change to the game's turn economy was risky but ends up making the game much for free-flowing and approachable for newcomers. 
"The sequel brings a host of important changes that improve on the original’s ideas rather than throw them out the window," Giovanni Colantonio wrote in a four-star review of the game. "Less rigid combat, a greater emphasis on exploration, and a stronger approach to character building all make the sequel feel as fresh as the original did in 2017."
The game's story and visuals are full of charm too, making it feel like a first-party Nintendo game even though it was developed by Ubisoft Milan. Although it's not the only fantastic Nintendo Switch game to come out this month, Switch players can't go wrong in picking this one up. Mario + Rabbids: Sparks of Hope is available now exclusively for Nintendo Switch. 
A Plague Tale: Requiem
A Plague Tale: Requiem - "End of Innocence" Gameplay Trailer | Xbox & Bethesda Games Showcase 2022
A Plague Tale: Innocence was a surprise sleeper hit in 2019, following a young brother and sister as they try to survive during an Inquisition and plague in the 1300s. Its sequel, A Plague Tale: Requiem, ups the ante on almost all accounts: there's more story, more combat, and more rats to chase the siblings. It's a beautiful game, one of the best-looking on current-gen yet, even if its story about violence gets a little muddled.  
"A Plague Tale: Requiem is a fantastic sequel on several counts," Giovanni Colantonio wrote in a 3.5-star review. "It improves on its predecessor in just about every way by finely tuning its stealth and navigation systems, adding more gameplay variety, and delivering a visually stunning world that puts games with much larger budgets to shame. Its weak spot comes down to its messy storytelling, which exposes the thematic limits of a medium that’s over-reliant on violence as its primary form of interaction."
For a AA game from a somewhat smaller team at Asobo Studio, A Plague Tale: Requiem is a really impressive-looking current-gen game that expands on the formula established in its predecessor. If The Last of Us Part II's story about violence annoyed you, though, parts of this game might feel like a slog to you as well. A Plague Tale: Requiem is available now for PC, PS5, and Xbox Series X/S, with a cloud version playable on Nintendo Switch.
Bayonetta 3
Bayonetta 3 - Ways of the Witch - Nintendo Switch
Despite a voice-acting controversy leading up to its launch, Bayonetta 3 didn't disappoint upon release, launching to critical acclaim. PlatinumGames is known for its stylish action games, and the Bayonetta series remains its crown jewel. With a bombastic opening and fast-paced combat that feels great and rewards skillful combos and dodges, Bayonetta 3 was worth the eight-year wait. The game does push the Nintendo Switch to its limits, though. 
"Bayonetta 3 is the series’ wildest entry to date, mixing PlatinumGames’ knack for fast-paced combat with unbelievably entertaining set pieces that just get bigger and bigger," Giovanni Colantonio's four-star review of Bayonetta 3 explains. "The massive scope of it all makes for some sloppy moments, both technically and narratively, but you’ll be hard-pressed to find an action game that’s having as much fun as this one."
Even though the discourse around this game was messy leading up to its launch, don't let that prevent you from checking this great game out. PlatinumGames continues to prove that no one can make action games that feel quite as refined and satisfying as its games. Bayonetta 3 is available now for Nintendo Switch. 
Ghostbusters: Spirits Unleashed
Ghostbusters: Spirits Unleashed - Now Hiring!
Illfonic's track record with 4v1 horror games based on famous franchises isn't great, but they've finally nailed the formula with Ghostbusters: Spirits Unleashed. Unlike Friday the 13th: The Game or Predator: Hunting Grounds, Ghostbusters: Spirits Unleashed feels polished, decently balanced, and doesn't take too long to get you into a match. Though an asymmetrical multiplayer game where one player haunts a building as a ghost and four Ghostbusters try to hunt them down and trap them wouldn't be my first idea for a Ghostbusters game, Illfonic nailed that concept here.
You can really tell they love this franchise too, as the Firehouse is lovingly recreated to serve as your base of operations between missions. Dan Aykroyd and Ernie Hudson even return to voice their characters in this game and do it well, making it feel like a more credible licensed game. While Ghostbusters video games can be hit or miss, Ghostbusters: Spirits Unleashed will provide a good time for those looking for a new game to play with friends. Ghostbusters: Spirits Unleashed is available now for PC, PS4, PS5, Xbox One, and Xbox Series X/S. 
New Tales from the Borderlands
New Tales from the Borderlands - Official Announce Trailer
Tales from the Borderlands was one of Telltale's best games, so it was great to see Gearbox Montreal finally deliver a follow-up, even if it features an entirely new cast. The aptly titled New Tales from the Borderlands follows a scientist named Anu, her hustler brother Octavio, and frogurt shop owner Fran as they find an object that can heal any injury and garner the attention of the evil corporation Tediore. 
"Thanks to entertaining writing, strong characters and performances, and a different game engine that enables more seamless cinematography, I’d recommend New Tales from the Borderlands to fans of the original and those yearning for a very traditional Telltale-like experience," I wrote in a four-star review of New Tales from the Borderlands.
Although it doesn't really push the boundaries of what a narrative adventure game can be from a gameplay perspective, New Tales from the Borderlands tells a captivating story that should entertain fans of this sci-fi series. New Tales from the Borderlands is available now for PC, PS4, PS5, Xbox One, Xbox Series X/S, and Nintendo Switch. 
Marvel Snap
MARVEL SNAP GAMEPLAY TRAILER | AVAILABLE WORLDWIDE NOW
Mobile games don't have the best reputation, but Marvel Snap is one of the most entertaining games I've played this year. It's a collectible card game based on the Marvel superhero universe where players fight for control of at least two of three locations, playing cards at the same time each turn. Add special location and card abilities on top of that, and you have a speedy card game with a whole lot of depth. And if you want to risk it, you can snap during a match to double your rewards. While its progression system to acquire cards is still flawed, even basic starter decks are fun to use in Marvel Snap.
Microtransactions are present in Marvel Snap but aren't intrusive. You can buy a season pass or gold that can be used to acquire new card variants or currencies to level cards up, but those are purely visual upgrades. Marvel Snap is the best mobile game of 2022, and I highly recommend that fans of Marvel or card games check it out when they can. It's available for free on the iOS App Store and Android's Google Play Store. 
The Case of the Golden Idol
The Case of the Golden Idol - Official Release Date Trailer
Ever since playing Return of the Obra Dinn, I've learned that I love a good deduction game. We've gotten a few great ones this year, like Strange Horticulture, but The Case of the Golden Idol is an absolute standout. The point-and-click game places players in different murder scenes and asks them to piece together what happened. To do that, they'll need to click on objects scattered around and collect keywords like names and verbs. The goal is to fill out a Madlibs-style crime report in each level, deducing who killed who just from clever sleuthing.
It starts simply enough, with a scene of one man pushing another off a cliff. However, it escalates from there in complex and surprising ways. By the end of the game, I'd uncovered a massive conspiracy that revolved around a creepy cult, a corrupt political party, and a mysterious golden idol capable of performing magic spells. If you're looking for a challenging mystery game, you can check it out on PC. ~ Giovanni Colantonio
Gotham Knights
Gotham Knights - Official Cinematic Launch Trailer
I've saved Gotham Knights for last because it's the most divisive game on this list. WB Games Montreal's first game in nine years takes some bold narrative swings, following four of Batman's sidekicks as they fend off the Court of Owls in Gotham following Batman's death. It also lets you go on patrol and explore the entirety of Gotham City with a friend. That said, some have been turned off by some gameplay issues and technical problems, so this game isn't for everyone.
"It’s not as good as the best Batman games from the last decade due to a lack of gameplay ambition and performance issues," I wrote in a three-and-a-half-star review of Gotham Knights. "Still, it overcomes those flaws to entertain Batman fans who have always wanted to play a game that lets them explore and defend the streets of Gotham with a friend."
While Gotham Knights isn't perfect, diehard Batman fans should still get a kick out of its story and patrolling the streets of Gotham City in co-op. There's simply no other Batman video game that's quite like this, for better and for worse. Gotham Knights is available for PC, PS5, and Xbox Series X/S, but be aware of its technical issues before deciding which platform to pick the game up on. 

Read more
E3 2023 returns in June with separate business and consumer days
Logo for E3 2023.

E3 2023 will return as an in-person event from June 13 to June 16, 2023, as announced by ReedPop today.

The Entertainment Software Association (ESA) already revealed that E3 will return in 2023, but now we know exactly when the event will take place, along with several other key details. E3 will once again take place at the Los Angeles Convention Center after a four-year hiatus, but will incorporate separate days for industry professionals and general consumers.

Read more