Skip to main content

The first reactions to Gladiator II launch the sequel into the Oscar race

Paul Mescal wields a sword and stares.
Paramount Pictures

It’s been more than 20 years since Ridley Scott’s Gladiator premiered and fought all the way to the Best Picture Oscar. Gladiator II is set to hit theaters next month, and we’re now seeing the first reactions to the movie online.

Happy Sad Confused host Josh Horowitz writes that the movie is “pretty f**king great,” while Variety‘s Clayton Davis highlighted a few of the film’s central performers: “I found Paul Mescal’s work as Lucius to be one of the film’s most honest surprises. This is Denzel Washington, having the time of his life in one of his most killer roles yet. A third Oscar could very well come his way,” he wrote.

Gladiator II | New Trailer (2024 Movie) - Paul Mescal, Pedro Pascal, Denzel Washington, Ridley Scott

Film journalist Scott Manzel adds: “Gladiator II is Ridley Scott’s best film since The Martian. A big, bloody and bada** action spectacle that builds upon the legacy of the original.”

Recommended Videos

Matt Brennan of the Los Angeles Times called the movie “the ‘we are so back’ of bloody costume epics.”

These rave responses are certainly getting fans excited, but they’re also a boon for Paramount Pictures, which has positioned the film as a major awards contender. The movie is set 16 years after the first installment, and follows Paul Mescal’s Lucius, who was a boy in the first film, as he is forced into slavery and pushed into the ring, just like his father was.

Scott has not always been met with a warm reception for his recent releases, and some of the reaction to Gladiator II suggests that it could be his best directorial effort in a decade. Even so, he has a long track record of awards success, and that’s something that Paramount is hoping will continue with this film. You can see more reactions to the movie below:

Welcome back to the f*king movies!

That sums up #GladiatorII. Ridley Scott's best directorial effort since "Black Hawk Down." I found Paul Mescal's work as Lucius to be one of the film's most honest surprises. This is Denzel Washington, having the time of his life in one of his… pic.twitter.com/5ETqmXdbDD

— Clayton Davis (@ByClaytonDavis) October 19, 2024

GLADIATOR 2 is an absolute triumph, Ridley Scott places you in the action of the arena centered on legacy and honor amping up the blood, battles,and biceps for something so deliciously cinematic and Machiavellian. Pedro Pascal, Paul Mescal, & Joseph Quinn certified movie stars. pic.twitter.com/0oy0jjrRUH

— Jillian🫧 (@JillianChili) October 19, 2024

denzel washington is having the time of his LIFE in gladiator two. watching him chew up material worthy of his talent was an honor. pic.twitter.com/aoxap2mSZS

— kenzie xcx 🐦‍⬛ (@kenzvanunu) October 19, 2024

GLADIATOR II works best as an acting showcase for Paul Mescal, Denzel Washington, & Joseph Quinn. It's largely uneven & lacks the emotional punch of the first film.

However, Ridley Scott's direction is unhinged, framing this as an epic Roman opera. The visuals get the job done. pic.twitter.com/R0xRDFTuwX

— Andrew J. Salazar (@AndrewJ626) October 19, 2024

GLADIATOR II is a true epic and Ridley Scott’s best in years. Paul Mescal is a great action star without sacrificing his indie grit, a worthy heir to the throne. Denzel Washington EATS every line and costume without ever overplaying. #GladiatorII pic.twitter.com/eKY2UqDNPi

— Erik Anderson (@awards_watch) October 19, 2024

Joe Allen
Joe Allen is a freelance writer at Digital Trends, where he covers Movies and TV. He frequently writes streaming…
First look at Gladiator II previews battle between Paul Mescal and Pedro Pascal
Paul Mescal stares with a confused look on face.

Paul Mescal heads to the arena to battle Pedro Pascal in the first look at Gladiator II, Ridley Scott's highly anticipated sequel to the Oscar-winning Gladiator.

In the images shared by Vanity Fair, Mescal plays Lucius, the former heir to the Empire and son of Lucilla (Connie Nielsen), who returns for the sequel. Lucilla sent Lucius to live in Numidia as a young boy. When the film opens, Lucius is peacefully in Numidia with his wife and child when Roman armies infiltrate his home.

Read more
Gladiator is on Netflix in October. Does it still hold up?
Russell Crowe standing and yelling in a scene from Gladiator.

Ridley Scott's epic historical drama Gladiator remains one of the best films in his long and prestigious career. Russel Crowe stars as Maximus Decimus Meridius, a Roman general who earns the favor of the ailing emperor Marcus Aurelius. However, he is betrayed by the emperor's jealous son, Commodus, who kills Marcus Aurelius and sizes the throne of Rome. After escaping arrest and discovering his family has been murdered by Commodus' men, Maximus is sold into slavery, becoming a renowned gladiator in a quest to avenge his family and kill Commodus.

Gladiator won the Best Picture Oscar at the 2001 ceremony, with Crowe winning Best Actor. The film has aged like fine wine, with many considering it among the best of the 2000s. It successfully reinvented the sword-and-sandal genre and revitalized mainstream interest in ancient Greece and Rome. Moreover, it heavily influenced the historical genre in the new millennium, setting the standard for what was to come. Gladiator is back on Netflix in October, which, coupled with the already-announced sequel starring Oscar-nominee Paul Mescal, should be reason enough for fans to want to check out this timeless gem. And they should, for Gladiator is an epic, riveting, cathartic movie; there are plenty of reasons to watch it, but here are three that should be more than enough.
The stunning production values

Read more
Everything coming to PBS in November 2024
Rachel Shenton and Nicholas Ralph in All Creatures Great and Small.

There are no new British dramas premiering on PBS in November, but there's more than enough programming to see you through the penultimate month of 2024. Ken Burns is premiering his new documentary, Leonardo da Vinci, about the world's most famous Renaissance man, artist, and inventor. And PBS has several other documentary and nature programs slated to run throughout the month.

PBS' non-partisan coverage of the 2024 presidential election will culminate on Tuesday, November 5. But if you're really missing your British dramas, there are encore presentations of All Creatures Great & Small and Call the Midwife coming as well.

Read more