Skip to main content
  1. Home
  2. Computing
  3. News

The Microsoft Surface Pro 4 may be beautiful, but its firmware isn't

By

pc sales recovering led by detachable tablets surface pro 4 hero
Microsoft has worked hard to convince the world it has transformed over the last few years, and a lot of that effort has gone into new hardware, be it the Xbox One or the Microsoft Surface. The argument is obvious. Redmond’s big-wigs want to convince the world that, like Apple, it can produce a complete hardware and software platform users can trust.

In theory, it’s a sensible move that should mean a better experience for users, and bigger numbers in Microsoft’s financial reports. Yet the Surface Pro 4 proves that even the best ideas can be difficult to execute.

The Pro’s problems are the shotgun spread of follies that have annoyed PC users for decades. The display often refuses to wake after the system is put to sleep — a hard restart is the only fix. On other occasions, plugging the Pro 4 into an external monitor causes open windows to freak out and collapse into a jumble of mis-aligned elements. Closing and re-opening them is the only fix. And Wi-Fi still refuses to work reliably in some locations for no apparent reason, including the Digital Trends office. I’ve become well acquainted with the “Connected, No Internet” status.

Related

I’m okay giving up repairability, but only in a bargain for stability.

Individually, these problems are minor. Together, they pick away at my confidence in the device. It remains true that the Surface Pro 4 is sleek, light, and powerful, and has a great keyboard. When firing on all cylinders it’s a beautiful piece of engineering, and those who don’t keep up to date with the latest in PC hardware still comment on it. I doubt MacBook owners receive more longing glances at the local coffee shop.

When these admirers ask how I like the device, I tell them I like it a lot – but. But what? It has issues. Those I’ve already mentioned have become familiar to me, but others visit without warning and leave no trace. Last week, only half the lock-screen opened when I swiped it away. The other half remained stuck until I put the Pro 4 to sleep and tried again. That never happened before, and hasn’t happened since.

As a PC enthusiast, I’ve come to accept bugs as the cost of a relatively open platform. My home-built desktop computer has its own quirks, as did every other desktop I’ve built before it, and every laptop I’ve had a chance to use for more than one month at a time.

But the Surface Pro 4 isn’t part of an open platform. It’s a locked down, purpose-built device which received a repair-ability score of 2 out of 10 in iFixit’s teardown. Upgrading or repairing it is mostly out of the question.

I’m okay with that, but only as part of an implicit bargain. If I give up the ability to tinker, I should receive design and stability that’s otherwise impossible. Microsoft only delivers on the first part of that deal. The Surface Pro 4 feels like a million bucks, but reliable? Intuitive? Stable? I don’t think so.

That’s a problem, and perhaps more so for Microsoft as a company than the Surface Pro 4 as a device. The Pro remains the best 2-in-1 device despite its woes, but if Microsoft wants us to believe in Windows as a platform – a family of devices, where hardware and software work together – it has to do better.

Editors' Recommendations

Topics
Matthew S. Smith
Matthew S. Smith
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Matthew S. Smith is the former Lead Editor, Reviews at Digital Trends. He previously guided the Products Team, which dives…
Turns out DirectStorage isn’t killing frame rates in Forspoken after all
Frey is handcuffed and guarded in Forspoken.

Yesterday, we published that DirectStorage might be killing your frame rate in Forspoken. This claim was based on some early testing from the PC Games Hardware YouTube channel, which claimed upwards of a 10% drop in frame rate when using DirectStorage. As some new testing has proven, that's has turned out to not be true.

It's a classic case of assuming on my part, and you know what they say about that. Although generally a reliable German source for PC hardware coverage, the YouTube channel didn't take into account loading screens when running its benchmarks. Naturally, a SATA SSD took longer to load than a PCIe SSD, boosting the average frame rate for the slower drive.

Read more
The dream isn’t over — AMD’s RX 7900 XTX may still hit 3GHz
The RX 7900 XTX.

Prior to AMD's launch of its new RDNA 3 GPUs, the rumor mill has been running wild with speculation about clock speeds on the new flagships. Some sources said that the cards would be able to hit 3GHz; 4GHz has also been floated around as a highly unbelievable, but enticing theory. Now that we know more about the Radeon RX 7900 XTX and RX 7900 XT, it's safe to say they won't be hitting 3GHz, let alone 4GHz.

With that said, it seems that 3GHz for RDNA 3 is not entirely out of the question -- it just seems very unlikely to happen on AMD's own reference models. Here's what we know.

Read more
All the reasons the new Surface devices are worse than before
The Surface Pro 9 with the Type Cover keyboard lifted up.

We expect tech to get better with each generation. After all, what's the point of releasing a new version of your product if it's not better than the previous version?

It's the question I had after reviewing the new Surface Pro 9 and Surface Laptop 5. There are plenty of good things about these new Surface devices, but there are a few ways they're actually worse than their predecessors, the Surface Pro 8 and Surface Laptop 4. That's not what you want in a launch of new products, especially when the competition continues to move forward.

Read more