Skip to main content

One woman was so annoyed by the Windows 10 update, she sued — and won

Windows 10
Bill Roberson/Digital Trends
Although we might still be a little confused about why most people haven’t updated to Windows 10 yet, there are certainly some cases where the change doesn’t make sense. Microsoft annoyed a lot of people recently when it made a few changes to its Windows 10 upgrade procedure, but perhaps no one as much as Teri Goldstein, who just won $10,000 in a courtroom after she sued Microsoft over the practice.

The instance that so aggravated Goldestein was when Microsoft changed how its upgrade panel worked. Traditionally hitting the red X in the corner would close the window down. While it still did that when Microsoft made its tweak, it also switched Windows 10 to a “recommended,” upgrade, which meant that closing that window down would begin the download and installation.

It didn’t matter if you were in the middle of something important, or as is the case with Goldstein, that your PC wasn’t up to the task of running it. Following the unrequested upgrade, she found her system running very slowly and even grinding to a halt at times.

She called Microsoft to complain, but when no remedy was found, she sued the tech giant. Amazingly, she walked away with $10,000 after taking on one of the world’s most powerful corporations.

That’s not to say that Microsoft threw the legal kitchen sink at her. It filed an appeal against the judgment, but dropped that a few weeks ago. While it did say in a statement that it still rejected the decision, it did not want to incur any more legal costs, according to Extremetech.

The bad PR that would have been generated from battling a lady in a courtroom is unlikely to have been worth it, either. Especially when there are just a few weeks left to grab the free upgrade for Windows 10. Microsoft is understandably keen to have everyone move over, so the last thing it needs to cap off a year where it has pushed upgrading on people is for it to appear even more insistent than it has so far.

Editors' Recommendations

Jon Martindale
Jon Martindale is the Evergreen Coordinator for Computing, overseeing a team of writers addressing all the latest how to…
Windows 11 has been causing problems with Intel graphics for months, and no one said a word
Microsoft has released a new Windows 11 feature that makes the OS photos app compatible with Apple's iClould.

If you're using Intel integrated graphics and you've been having some issues with DirectX apps, we may know the reason why -- outdated drivers paired with a recent Windows update.

According to Microsoft, a Windows 11 update may have caused some errors in Intel graphics. The update is not recent at all, so even if you haven't updated in the last few weeks, you may be affected.

Read more
Windows 11 vs. Windows 10: finally time to upgrade?
The screen of the Surface Pro 9.

Windows 11 is the newest version of Windows, and it's one of the best Windows versions released. Under the hood, though, it's very similar to Windows 10. We've compared Windows 11 and Windows 10 point for point in order to answer one question: Should you upgrade to the latest Windows OS?

We'll run down the biggest differences between Windows 11 and Windows 10, including how the Windows 11 2H22 Update changes things. Before diving in, keep in mind that Microsoft no longer sells new Windows 10 licenses. If you're upgrading from an older version of Windows, you'll need to go straight to Windows 11.
Windows 11 vs. Windows 10: what's new

Read more
Lagging in games? This Windows 11 update might fix the problem
Woman shouting with joy while playing games on a PC.

Microsoft has apparently resolved the gaming issues in the Windows 11 22H2 update, making it safe for anyone that hasn't updated yet to do so now.

The gaming problems were confirmed by Microsoft two weeks into November, following ongoing complaints from Windows gamers that had noticed popular games lagging. A safeguard hold was placed, stopping automatic update alerts but not preventing manual updates.

Read more