Skip to main content

What makes identical processors perform differently?

makes identical processors perform differently spectre13tperformance
Image used with permission by copyright holder

AMD and Intel publish official numbers indicating the settings at which a particular processor should run, and these figures are often taken as if they were cast in stone by fire from the sky. A processor is a processor, and two of the same kind should perform identically. Right?

Experience, however, tells a different story. We’ve tested numerous laptops over the years and have sometimes noticed that two different models with the same processor do not manage equivalent results in our benchmarks. The fastest and slowest laptops with the Core i5-4200U processor, for example, are separated by a gap of 25%.

Recommended Videos

The differences we see are the result of a range of variables that include system cooling, power profiles and manufacturer tweaks to performance. To illustrate the impact these factors can have, we’ve tested a single Ultrabook, the Editor’s Choice award-winning HP Spectre 13t, under a broad range of conditions. The results show that dramatic change which can be achieved with just few clicks.

Power preset testing

All Windows laptops ship with several different preset power plans that alter how the laptop operates. These settings are Power Saver, Balanced and High Performance. On our test laptop, the Balanced plan had been renamed to HP Recommended, but otherwise appeared to be a normal Windows 8 “Balanced” preset.

A look at the settings of each shows there are differences in maximum and minimum states for the processor. But do these settings make a difference? To find out, we used 7-Zip, a file compression utility that includes a handy benchmark which heavily relies on processor performance. We ran the benchmark five times at each preset, then averaged the scores.

powerpresetscores
Image used with permission by copyright holder

While the Balanced and High Performance plans delivered almost identical scores, the Power Saver preset drastically reduced performance by over 20%, putting a serious dent in 7-Zip’s benchmark results. That’s something you’d notice any time you performed a processor intensive task, and which may even result in a general sense of lethargy during daily use.

This just goes to show that power management is a very important part of overall speed. If your system feels slow, check the power plan. You may have forgotten to change it back from Power Saver the last time you traveled.

Presets performance while on battery power

Another factor we tested is how a system performs at different presets when unplugged. Power management settings typically reduce performance to enhance battery life – but by how much?

powerpresetbatterypower
Image used with permission by copyright holder

The difference is significant and impacted our test system at all power presets, not just Power Saver. The drop fell between 30 percent and 40 percent, with the largest gap between High Performance modes when plugged and un-plugged. This variable has the largest negative impact of any we tested. 

Clearly, plugging a laptop into an outlet is a good idea if you intend to run demanding software. This may seem obvious, but laptop owners often want to take advantage of their mobility by working from the nearest Starbucks or simply their living room couch. Doing so doesn’t impact functionality at first glance, but it can increase the amount of time some tasks require. Editing a video while unplugged, for example, could become frustrating.

Temperature testing

Most of Intel’s processors include a feature called Turbo Boost that automatically increases processor clock speed when needed and when thermal headroom allows. Since this feature is tied to the thermals of a system, it makes sense that a processor may perform differently at different ambient temperatures.

To test this, we put ran the 7-Zip benchmark in three different scenarios; a normal room heated to a typical temperature of 68 degrees, an outdoors area with an ambient temperature of 42 degrees, and six inches above a heater, which raised the immediate ambient temperature to 92 degrees. All tests were conducted at the High Performance preset.

temptesting
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Heating the laptop caused the most dramatic difference. While the Spectre 13t did not shut itself down at any point, the CPU’s temperature sensor reported a maximum reading of 71 degrees Celsius, which roughly translates to 160 degrees Fahrenheit. Overall performance was reduced by a little more than 10 percent, as the processor could not increase its clock as aggressively as it could at room temperature.

Placing the Ultrabook outside had a big impact on internal temperatures, which were lowered by over 12 degrees Celsius to a maximum of 56 degrees at full load, but this didn’t make the Spectre much quicker. 7-Zip’s score increased barely more than 100 points, an improvement of less than two percent.  This simply shows that the Spectre 13t’s cooling works as intended, providing little room for improvement when it is enhanced. 

Conclusion

These tests show that power presets not only matter, but are the single largest contributor to performance differences from identical hardware. We normally test laptops under the Balanced preset, so it’s theoretically not an issue in reviews, but your experience at home may be different because manufacturers can sometimes be very aggressive with their customized power plans. We’ve seen this in  Toshiba laptops, for example, which often ship with an “Eco mode” that automatically activates when a system is unplugged. Though it can extend battery life, it also holds back performance.

Temperature is a factor too, and has the potential to hamper performance noticeably.  Though we’d have to test many laptops at different ambient temperatures to make an absolutely certain conclusion, our tests with the HP Spectre 13t suggest that a laptop with poor cooling will not perform as well as one with excellent cooling. The results also suggest that better performance can be achieved with better cooling, but the ceiling is not as high as the floor.

These numbers prove that two systems with the same processor may not offer the same performance out of the box, and the only way to know the difference is to view benchmark results. They also show that, while today’s laptops are often almost as quick as a desktop when plugged in, they can be substantially slower when unplugged.

Yet there is hope even for people who already own a laptop that’s not as quick as expected. While poor design can cause issues, the solution might be as simple as choosing a different power plan. Some problems really are that easy to solve!  

Topics
Matthew S. Smith
Matthew S. Smith is the former Lead Editor, Reviews at Digital Trends. He previously guided the Products Team, which dives…
What is laptop battery swelling?
battery life lie laptopbattery

We all want to get the most out of our laptops, and that includes doing what we can to extend the lives of our laptops' batteries. But sometimes, despite our best efforts, we can still run into situations where our batteries can get damaged. In this guide, we're taking a closer look at laptop battery swelling, its causes, and what you can do if your laptop shows signs of it.

What is laptop battery swelling?

Read more
This new Windows 10 feature promises better battery life and less fan noise
Screenshot showing battery life in Windows.

Microsoft is working on a new feature that can help tune the performance of your PC's processor for both better battery life and reduced fan noise. Known as EcoQoS, it's now in beta testing with Windows Insiders and promises to make Windows 10 a lot more efficient.

According to Raymond Li, program manager for Windows Fundamentals, this new EcoQoS feature is about better energy consumption and reduced power and thermal throttling. It's all accomplished with what's known as a new "quality of service level" inside Windows 10, which works better with certain background processes that do not have a significant performance or latency requirement.

Read more
How long does your laptop last on a charge? Here’s how to find out
school computers chromebooks more than apples budgetlaptops acerchromebook15

Manufacturers typically list a static number regarding laptop battery life, like 10 hours. In the real world, battery life varies. What you do on any given day reflects on how the battery performs overall. Learning to monitor laptop battery life is essential -- it's the difference between finishing that report over coffee or kicking yourself because you didn't bring your power cord.

Luckily, there are a few ways you can get an accurate measure of battery life, not just for your model of laptop, but for your specific machine and your usage habits. Follow the steps below for some easy-to-use methods.
How to configure your laptop battery settings
Before we start, make sure your power plan configuration is how you want it to run normally. Windows works hard to provide a long-lasting battery at the default settings, but if you'd like to tweak it to your particular usage, you can.

Read more