Red Hat, Novell Linux Sued on Patent Claims

By Geoff Duncan October 12, 2007

Red Hat, Novell Linux Sued on Patent Claims

Patent holding company IP Innovation has filed a patent infringement lawsuit against Red Hat and Novell, claiming their Linux products violate a patent on "user interface with multiple workspaces for sharing display system objects." The lawsuit seems to target the graphic interfaces used by Red Hat’s and Novell’s Linux products, rather than the core Linux operating system, but the suit may nontheless raise doubts amongst organizations and enterprises concerned Linux may be vulnerable on the intellectual property front—a perception software giant Microsoft would be all-to-happy to encourage.

The lawsuit alleges that Red Hat’s and Novell’s Linux products infringe on U.S. patent 5,072,412, which dates back to 1987 and originally came from the famous Xerox PARC. The suit seeks $20 million in damages and injunctive relief.

IP Innovations has no products of its own; rather, the company is a patent-holding subsidiary of Acacia Research that exists solely to license a portfolio of about 140 technology patents and pursue infringement claims against anyone it believes is violating those patents.

Although Linux advocates have been consistently confident that the core Linux operating system is not encumbered by patent claims, individual Linux implementations could be more vulnerable. IP Innovation’s claim against Red Hat and Novell could carry some momentum: in April of 2007, the company sued Apple for violating the same patent in its Mac OS X operating system; Apple settled with IP Innovation for an undisclosed amount.

Some industry watchers are noting that two former Microsoft executives recently joined Acacia as high-level executives, leading to speculation Acacia might be acting as a proxy for Microsoft’s oft-repeated assertions that Linux violates Microsoft patents.

Novell and Red Hat have yet to comment on the suit.

Editors' Recommendations

Former Digital Trends Contributor

Geoff Duncan writes, programs, edits, plays music, and delights in making software misbehave. He's probably the only member…

Computing

Trying to buy a GPU in 2023 almost makes me miss the shortage

Two AMD Radeon RX 7000 graphics cards on a pink surface.

The days of the GPU shortage are long over, but somehow, buying a GPU is harder than ever -- and that sentiment has very little to do with stock levels. It's just that there are no obvious candidates when shopping anymore.

In a generation where no single GPU stands out as the single best graphics card, it's hard to jump on board with the latest from AMD and Nvidia. I don't want to see another GPU shortage, but the state of the graphics card market is far from where it should be.
This generation is all over the place

Computing

HP printers are heavily discounted in Best Buy’s flash sale

The HP - OfficeJet Pro 8034e Wireless All-In-One Inkjet Printer on a desk with a smartphone.

There’s good news in store if you’re looking to land a new printer at a discount this weekend. Best Buy is having a 48-hour flash sale on HP printers, with several that can compete with the best printers seeing some good prices. HP is almost always one of the best laptop brands, and it’s one of the same when it comes to printers. So if you’re looking for a new home or office printer, read onward on how to save on an HP printer at Best Buy.
HP DeskJet 2755e — $60, was $85

The HP DeskJet 2755e is a good entry-level printer. It’s got you covered if your printing needs are pretty basic, or if you don’t need to print in mass. This is a color InkJet printer, which makes it good for almost all uses. It can also make copies and scan in color, and it has mobile and wireless printing functionality. You can get set up quickly and easily with the HP Smart app that guides you through the setup process, and you can also use this app to print, scan and copy documents from your phone.

Computing

This tiny ThinkPad can’t quite keep up with the MacBook Air M2

While the laptop industry continues to move toward 14-inch laptops and larger, the 13-inch laptop remains an important category. One of the best is the Apple MacBook Air M2, with an extremely thin and well-built chassis, great performance, and incredibly long battery life.

Lenovo has recently introduced the third generation of its ThinkPad X1 Nano, one of the lightest laptops we've tested and a good performer as well. It's stiff competition, but which of these two diminutive laptops stands apart?
Specs and configurations