Xbox 360 victorious at end of year-long Microsoft-versus-Motorola patent battle

By Anthony John Agnello March 25, 2013

xbox-360

When it comes to fighting back lawsuits related to the Xbox 360, Microsoft’s got a pretty spectacular track record. After more than a year of back and forth battling with Google’s Motorola, the International Trade Commission (ITC) officially cleared Microsoft of having infringed on Motorola-owned patents in the design of the Xbox 360. “It is held that a violation of section 337 of the Tariff Act, as amended, has not occurred,” wrote ITC Judge David Shaw on Friday. Put another way: Motorola can take its proposed royalty fees and stuff them in an old Razr flip phone.

It all started back in 2012 when Motorola claimed that a number of Microsoft products infringed on five patents held by Motorola. The patents in question related to video encoding technology as well as ActiveSync tech, the apps in Microsoft products that let them sync with mobile phones and tablets. The Xbox 360 was one of the products that came under fire.

Recommended Videos

Microsoft didn’t deny that it used technology patented by Motorola, only that Motorola wasn’t allowing Microsoft to license said technology at a reasonable rate as dictated by FRAND commitments. Motorola instead wanted Microsoft to pay a 2.25-percent royalty fee on every Xbox 360 and other infringing Microsoft product sold, which would cost, according to Microsoft, about $4 billion per year.

It’s surprising that Shaw ultimately determined that the Xbox 360 wasn’t guilty of infringing on those precious patents. It was Shaw who suggested that the Xbox 360 be banned from sale in the United States until the matter was settled, even going so far as to say that Microsoft should be blocked from importing consoles from its Chinese manufacturers. A number of companies came to Microsoft’s defense, particularly Acitvision Blizzard, which was worried about how an Xbox ban might affect its Call of Duty: Black Ops 2 sales. (Seeing as how the majority of annual Call of Duty sales are on Xbox 360, the ban would have hurt CoD sales.)

Microsoft won a decisive victory in the battle against Motorola in December, though, preventing the Xbox 360 from getting banned in both the U.S. and Germany. Judge James Robart took Microsoft’s side, claiming that Motorola was demanding unreasonable licensing fees on FRAND-type tech. Now the matter is wholly settled.

Topics

Anthony John Agnello

Former Digital Trends Contributor

Anthony John Agnello is a writer living in New York. He works as the Community Manager of Joystiq.com and his writing has…

Gaming

How to revive dead companions in Baldur’s Gate 3

Withers offering services to the player in Baldur's Gate 3.

You're given a good bit of leeway during battles in Baldur's Gate 3 before you or a companion actually bites the dust for good. While in battle, if a teammate does take enough damage to drop, they aren't dead then and there. Instead, they will be downed with a chance to roll every turn to get back up. If they roll successfully three times, the battle ends, or you use another character to pick them up, they're good. If they fail that roll three times, however, they will be completely dead. That can be harsh when you've become attached to certain characters and want to further their stories, so you'll be looking for any way you can to bring them back. Thankfully you do have a few options for reviving companions in Baldur's Gate 3, but just like respeccing, they aren't so obvious.
Pay Withers to bring them back

Withers is a friendly undead you can find in a secret room in the Dank Crypt found inside the Overgrown Ruins. After finding and speaking to him in his sarcophagus, he will offer you various services, one of which is bringing back any dead companions. He won't do this out of the kindness of his heart (probably because it isn't beating) and will charge you a heavy fine of 200 gold to do so. Still, that's a small price to pay to bring back a beloved character. Once paid, that character will appear in your camp where they would normally be, so there's no need to go back to their corpse and find them.
Use a scroll of Revivfy or learn it

Gaming

Every video game delay that has happened in 2023 so far

The player skates toward the moon in Skate Story.

Few things feel as inevitable in the video game industry as delays. Ever since the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic, game delays have only become more and more common as developers find previously set timelines unrealistic and adjust their release plans accordingly. More than halfway through 2023, we've already seen some notable AAA games like Suicide Squad: Kill the Justice League, Skull & Bones, and Pragmata delayed pretty heavily. Because video game release date delays are so common, it can be tough to keep track of every game that has had its launch date shifted in some way.
That's why, just as we did in 2021 and 2022, Digital Trends is rounding up every game delay that's announced throughout 2023. Here are the high-profile ones that have happened so far, listed chronologically by their new intended release dates.
The Dark Pictures: Switchback VR (March 16)

As Until Dawn: Rush of Blood is one of the best games for PlayStation VR, The Dark Pictures: Switchback VR, Supermassive Games' PlayStation VR2 successor, is a highly anticipated launch title for the upcoming VR headset. Unfortunately, it will no longer make PlayStation VR2's February 22 launch and will instead be released on March 16. On Twitter, a message from Supermassive Games says this delay will ensure that players "receive the most polished, terrifying experience possible" at release. The game was released on that date to mixed reviews.
Atelier Ryza 3: Alchemist of the End & the Secret Key (March 24)

Gaming

Is Remnant 2 cross-platform?

Three characters shoot at a boss in Remnant 2.

Aside from the focus on firearms and integrating some randomly generated environments, the Remnant series sets itself apart from other souls-like games mainly with its focus on co-op. Both titles encourage you to team up with two friends to fight your way through the mutated monsters that await. After so many years of progress in terms of multiplatform games incorporating full cross-platform support, you might assume Remnant 2 will follow suit and let you make a group with anyone regardless of what platform they're on. However, the truth may be a bit more disappointing. Before you make plans with your squad, here's what you need to know about Remnant 2's cross-platform support.
Is Remnant 2 cross-platform?

Unfortunately, Remnant 2 does not have cross-platform play between PS5, Xbox Series X or PC -- and there's no word about it being added in the future.