Skip to main content

The Nest Secure included a microphone no one knew about — except Google

After the hacking fiasco a few weeks ago, Nest users have been more on edge about their security devices than ever before. The recent discovery of a built-in, hidden microphone on the Nest Guard, part of the Nest Secure security system, has only served to further exacerbate those concerns.

Consumers might never have known the microphone existed had Google not announced support for Google Assistant on the Nest Secure. This sounds like a great addition, except for one little problem: users didn’t know their Nest Secure had a microphone. None of the product documentation disclosed the existence of the microphone, nor did any of the packaging.

If your first thought on hearing this news is that Google was spying on you or doing something equally sinister, you aren’t alone. Ray Walsh, digital privacy expert at BestVPN.com, said “Nest’s failure to disclose the onboard microphone included in its secure home security system is a massive oversight. Nest’s parent company Google claims that the feature was only made available to consumers who activated the feature manually. Presumably, nobody did this; because the feature wasn’t advertised until an update released earlier this February.”

Many consumers were outraged by the discovery. Although Google claims the microphone had never been turned on and was only included in the device for potential future upgrades, the fact remains that the company sold a product with the potential to spy on its users. Even if Google themselves did not use the microphone, the Nest Secure is a web-connected device. Hackers could have gained access to listen in on private conversations, and consumers would have been none the wiser.

Google claimed responsibility for the oversight, but it seems like it’s a bit too little, too late at this point. The discovery of a hidden microphone follows too closely on the heels of the Nest hacks for many customers to feel comfortable with the company or the product. No one assumes Google is an evil corporation with plans to steal personal information for an insidious reason, but in this era of heightened caution with regard to consumer privacy and mega-corporations, these discoveries seem to play on consumers’ worst fears.

Ray Walsh sums up the situation well: “… the question you have to ask yourself is – do you trust Google?”

Editors' Recommendations

Patrick Hearn
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Patrick Hearn writes about smart home technology like Amazon Alexa, Google Assistant, smart light bulbs, and more. If it's a…
Lenovo Smart Display vs. Google Nest Hub
5 google assistant smart display features worth checking out lenovo 10 inch with 768x768

Many of us are investing in home hubs, where we can get virtual butler service, smart home control, and organization of our smart home gear at our beck and call. While Amazon’s Echo devices and Google Nest Hubs are two of the granddaddies of home automation technology, Lenovo also makes a home automation hub that piggybacks on the power of the Google Assistant. So should you get the original Google Nest Hub or look to Lenovo’s Smart Display?
Does the Lenovo Smart Display work with Google Home?
Google Nest Hub Max John Velasco/Digital Trends

It’s important to note right out of the gate that both the Google Nest Home Hub and Hub Max are native Google devices, and obviously, Google Assistant is built-in and works seamlessly on these products. Google Assistant can do a lot for you, from answering questions to making calls and appointments, maintaining lists, and keeping you updated on the latest news.

Read more
This South Korean smart home hack is one more reason you should secure your home
Alexa listening indicator.

While most Americans were trying to take advantage of Black Friday sales last weekend, hackers in South Korea pulled off what is perhaps the most damaging hack in smart home history. The as-yet-unidentified hackers recorded photo and video from more than 700 different apartment complexes and held it ransom or sold it outright for Bitcoin.

The entire incident is the stuff of nightmares -- the realization of fears about the smart home industry and what it means to allow cameras and other recording devices into the home without sufficient safeguards in place.

Read more
Google Nest vs. Ring: Who has the better video doorbells?
Using the Nest Doorbell battery edition chime.

Ring and Google both have some of the best video doorbells on the market -- but which is the right choice for you? We’re going over all the details between these two video doorbell options, what their models look like, and which we think is the best pick for consumers.

Are you shopping for a video doorbell for Black Friday? That's a good idea, especially if you're looking to save. Ring doorbells in particular are likely to be discounted as they are an Amazon brand. But you'll need to know where to look first: Start with our guide on the best Black Friday Ring Doorbell deals.
Design and variety

Read more