Skip to main content

The Energy Star program saved you money for 25 years, but budget cuts could kill it

widely recognized energy star program could be cut energystar feat
Image used with permission by copyright holder
In early March, the Environmental Protection Agency awarded the Nest Learning Thermostat an Energy Star rating, currently the only thermostat on the market to have that distinction. A week later, E&E news noted that the White House plans to close out or transfer the Energy Star program. President Trump’s budget proposal, released today, confirms that it plans to eliminate more than 50 EPA programs, including Energy Star. The voluntary program, which the EPA introduced in 1992, saves homeowners and businesses billions of dollars a year.

“It’s a really simple, effective program,” Noah Horowitz, senior scientist and director of the Natural Resources Defense Council’s Center for Energy Efficiency, told Digital Trends. Those looking to buy an energy-efficient laptop, TV, washing machine, ceiling fan, or dozens of other product categories can check for the Energy Star blue-and-white logo and know what they’re getting. “There’s a lot of brand recognition, and all the manufacturers, retailers, and utilities have bought into it,” said Horowitz. “It’s delivered massive results.”

What’s behind the logo?

The aim of the program is to give people an easy way to spot energy-efficient equipment without having to compare kilowatt-hours. It compares fridges across manufacturers that are the same size and awards Energy Star designations to the ones that meet its standard. In addition, there’s the Energy Star Most Efficient program, which singles out the products that use the least energy among those that receive the rating. As manufacturers become better at meeting the standards — to the point where 50 percent of fridges on the market meet it — the EPA revises it, so fridge makers have to come up with new and innovative ways to save energy. But that’s only if they want the Energy Star label. “This is not a mandatory program,” said Horowitz.

Image used with permission by copyright holder

“Appliances tell an incredible story of energy efficiency, which has been achieved through a combination of mandatory federal standards and product innovation,” Jill Notini, vice president of communications and marketing for the Association of Home Appliance Manufacturers, told Digital Trends. “For example, an average 20-cubic-foot household refrigerator that was shipped last year used only as much energy as a 50-watt incandescent light bulb. While appliances with an Energy Star designation may be super efficient, even non-Energy Star appliances have dramatically increased their efficiency through standards and technology advances.”

Aiming for efficiency

The question is whether that’s a chicken-and-egg scenario, though. As manufacturers try to out-compete each other in energy efficiency, the innovations trickle down to less-expensive models, until they become standardized. Especially with appliances, customers are always looking for ways to reduce utility bills. “We do a lot of consumer research, and energy efficiency for appliance shoppers is always a very important consideration,” John Taylor, LG’s vice president of public affairs and communications, told Digital Trends. He said the company has been looking for ways to increase efficiency, regardless of whether products get the Energy Star label. The EPA awarded the company an Emerging Technology Award for its hybrid heat pump dryer in 2014. It was one of the technologies, along with sensors, that prompted Energy Star to start awarding labels to dryers that same year. “There wasn’t an Energy Star dryer program, but we were one of the companies that was pushing for that for years,” said Taylor.

“Even non-Energy Star appliances have dramatically increased their efficiency through standards and technology advances.”

There’s a reason the industry pushed for the logo on dryers: it’s a signal to customers. “Energy Star fills a need,” Lowell Ungar, a senior policy adviser for the American Council for an Energy-Efficient Economy, told Digital Trends. “Energy efficiency is not visible, but consumers care about it, and the EPA has managed the brand well so that consumers recognize the label and trust that it means real energy savings.”

“It’s kind of evolved to connote more than just energy efficiency,” said Taylor of the logo. “I think people correctly connect it to product quality and performance.” To qualify for the logo, manufacturers have to send their products to an approved lab for independent testing, and Energy Star performs “spot checks,” buying models from retailers to ensure customers are getting the same quality. “Without Energy Star, which is a trusted brand that has a lot of integrity, in the absence of it, all the manufacturers will make claims, some of which are not true,” said Horowitz. “It opens the door for a lot of greenwashing.” Greenwashing happens despite regulations, of course. In 2015, Dyson and Bosch counter-sued each other over claims that the latter was rigging its efficiency tests to make its vacuums seem more eco-friendly than they really were.

That’s why the EPA uses random checks and independent verification. “Energy Star is a voluntary program,” said Unger. “It only matters if consumers trust that labeled products save energy and money. So, it is important that an independent manager sets the criteria for the label through a rigorous and transparent process, and that reliable, independent testing ensures that the labeled products actually earn the label.”

Increased incentives

There’s another reason people might look for the logo when purchasing a new appliance or TV. Buying an Energy Star water heater could get you a rebate, though the amount varies based on where you live. Utilities have invested heavily in them, putting up over $5 billion for incentive programs in 2016, according to Horowitz. “If the whole program and its infrastructure goes away, I’m not sure the utilities are able to continue to offer those rebates, and without those rebates, a lot of the manufacturers lose the incentive to make their products as efficient as they are today,” he said.

Image used with permission by copyright holder

What exactly will happen to the Energy Star at this point isn’t clear. “We are not commenting at this early stage in the process,” Julia Valentine, an EPA spokesperson, told Digital Trends. It could become privatized or become part of the Department of Energy. “Moving the programs back to the Department of Energy makes sense because that is where the product knowledge resides, along with the development of the test procedures and standards which are the foundation for the Energy Star program,” said Notini.
Horowitz hopes the program survives, because he said it delivers over $30 billion in utility savings each year. “There’s a lot of great infrastructure here,” he said. “It would be a shame to see it go away.”

Edited 3/18/2017: Edited to correct Noah Horowitz’s title and the change the NRDC from National to Natural Resources Defense Council. 

Jenny McGrath
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Jenny McGrath is a senior writer at Digital Trends covering the intersection of tech and the arts and the environment. Before…
Early Black Friday chest freezer deals: up to 40% off today
The Insignia 7-cubic feet chest freezer placed in a garage.

Update 10/29/24: This starts our Black Friday coverage of chest freezers, and we like what we see so far. The following deals are from a variety of good brands, show a wide range of prices, and most importantly come in various sizes, so you can pick what is right for your home.

While Black Friday officially starts on November 29, retailers are getting started early this year. That means great early Black Friday deals, including on things like chest freezers. Here, we search high and low for the best deals on chest freezers to hit the market. That means we're looking at sources like Walmart's, Amazon's, and Best Buy's early Black Friday deals among others to get you the best deals possible. Whether you're wanting to store ice cream, meat, or a party's worth of frozen pizza, these are the best chest freezers for you.
Hisense 5 cu. ft. Garage Ready Chest Freezer — $165 $189 13% off

Read more
Best cordless drill early Black Friday deals: DeWalt and more
A DeWalt drill being used.

Update 10/28/24: This marks the beginning of our drill coverage for 2024's Black Friday shopping season, and all of the major brands have at least one great deal. While we're excited for what is to come, this is a fantastic start and there's really no reason to not go ahead and get prepped by buying something now.
If you're buying anything this Black Friday, there's a big chance you might want a drill/driver to go with it. A drill/driver is one part drill, one part (screw)driver and it can help out in many situations. For example, say you take part in one of these early Black Friday TV deals, you very well might want to wall mount it. Then, say you grab up an easy coffee maker from Keurig's early Black Friday deals. An extra side table in your study would sure go nice with that and a drill/driver could very well make the table's construction much easier.
Really, with so so many of your early Black Friday purchases, there might be a chance to pick up a cordless drill or driver and get to work. As such, we've compiled a list of the best cordless drill deals throughout Black Friday deals that are available now, so you can get a head start on prepping for the savings that are to come.

Skil Pwr Core 12 Drill/Driver — $50 $59 15% off

Read more
Best Roomba deals: Top robot vacuums from as little as $170
iRobot Roomba 692 Robot Vacuum.

If you come home and don't really look forward to doing the day-to-day dusting and vacuuming that's required to keep everything clean, then robot vacuums are a great solution. Probably one of the best-known brands is Roomba, and if you're looking to pick up a new one, then Roomba has a lot of great options you can pick from.. Whether you're looking for a budget-friendly option or something a little bit more high-end that comes with a self-emptying station, we've gone out and collected some of our favorite Roomba deals below.

That said, if you don't necessarily want a Roomba, you can check out these general robot vacuum deals, and for the more substantial messes, there are always these vacuum deals and cordless vacuum deals too.
iRobot Roomba i1 -- $170 $220 22% off

Read more