Skip to main content

Family files lawsuit against Apple, blames FaceTime for daughter’s death

how to use Split View on a Mac
Apple’s FaceTime proved to be a healing tool for one Digital Trends editor, but James and Bethany Modisette believe that Apple’s “less safe” FaceTime implementation is responsible for their daughter’s death, reports Courthouse News.

On December 24, 2014, the Modisettes were on Interstate 35, with James needing to slow the car down due to road congestion. The family’s car was then rear-ended by another car at 65 miles per hour, which left Moriah, one of the Modisettes’ daughters, with severe injuries that later resulted in her death.

Recommended Videos

When talking to police, the 20-year-old driver who crashed into the Modisettes’ car admitted to using FaceTime on his iPhone 6 Plus while driving. According to the Modisettes’ complaint, authorities found the FaceTime app open and a call in progress when they arrived at the scene.

The crux of the complaint, which was filed in the Santa Clara County Superior Court in California, does not concern itself with the driver that rear-ended the family’s vehicle. Instead, the lawsuit asserts that the driver’s conduct is “inextricably intertwined” with Apple’s failure to implement a FaceTime feature that renders the app inaccessible while someone is driving.

The complaint also chastised Apple for not implementing the aforementioned FaceTime lockout feature, even though the company has the patent for it. Finally, because the iPhone 6 Plus does not implement the technologies for the feature, the lawsuit claims Apple acted with intent to cause injury, with a “willful and knowing disregard of the rights and safety of another” in order to make a profit.

“Despite both the technology since 2008 and a patent on that technology so it could exploit its patent without competition for 20 years, defendant Apple has consistently and continuously failed to implement a safer, alternative design that would lock-out and prevent use of FaceTime while driving,” reads a relevant portion of the complaint.

The Modisettes’ lawsuit seeks damages, including punitive damages, and medical expenses. Digital Trends reached out to Apple for comment and will update accordingly.

Williams Pelegrin
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Williams is an avid New York Yankees fan, speaks Spanish, resides in Colorado, and has an affinity for Frosted Flakes. Send…
The best screen-time apps to get your digital life under control
Screen Time

It's easy to do just about anything with your smartphone. From paying your bills to ordering groceries, once-arduous tasks can be completed in minutes. If you're like many people, however, you may be concerned about the amount of time you're spending on your phone. Luckily, there are some excellent apps that can help you find a little balance. Here are our favorite apps to help you reduce screen time and reclaim your life.

See more

Read more
Apple may have killed off the iPhone XR, but it still stands the test of time
iPhone XR

As the iPhone 13 takes its place as the iPhone literally everyone should buy, the question still exists: Should I upgrade to the new iPhone, or should I keep my old one? To find out, I went back to a much older iPhone -- the 2018 iPhone XR -- for just over a week to see how well it would fare in 2021. Back when we reviewed it, we praised it as the "budget" iPhone to buy. This device was loaned to me by the folks at Back Market, so it's a refurb without all the dings and nicks that you'd have on an actively used phone.
A game changer with a legacy
The iPhone XR may be old now, but it's an important iPhone that preceded the current iPhones like the iPhone 11, iPhone 12, and the most recent iPhone 13. It's a phone that would be considered less than the "real" iPhone, but an iPhone nonetheless. Apple tried this sort of non-standard iPhone model with the SE and the iPhone 5C before. In many ways, the iPhone XR kicked off the standardization of Apple's lineup, and it also became one of the bestselling iPhones in its day. After using it, it's not a surprise.

Hardware that lasts and software that works
The iPhone XR's rounded corners, wide notch, and single camera combine late 2010s iPhone aesthetics with some of the older iPhone 6-style designs. It's a bit weightier than it should be, but the rounded corners mean that it doesn't dig into your fingers.

Read more
Apple’s iOS 15.1 and iPadOS 15.1 bring SharePlay, camera improvements, and more
iPhones with ios 15.

Apple is rolling out iOS 15.1 and iPadOS 15.1, its third update to the current generation of iOS since it rolled out alongside the iPhone 13. The iOS 15.1 update brings SharePlay, which lets multiple Apple users enjoy movies, music, and other content together during FaceTime calls; ProRes video recording on the iPhone 13 Pro and the iPhone 13 Pro Max, among other improvements to the camera; and some additions to the Home, Shortcuts, Translate, and Wallet apps.

Among the slew of new features that iOS 15.1 delivers, SharePlay is bound to get most of the attention. As its name indicates, SharePlay offers multiple shared experiences using FaceTime, from browsing the web together to watching synchronized movies or TV shows to sharing content across the Apple Music, Apple Fitness+, Apple TV, and other App Store apps. It also gives each user the ability to play, pause, rewind, or fast-forward movies, shows, or music and automatically lowers the volume of the content when it detects someone speaking.

Read more