Skip to main content

Can Apple be sued for allegedly creating app monopoly? Appeals court says yes

apple ios app monopoly case news store carrousel du louvre
Mikhail (Vokabre) Shcherbakov/Flickr
Apple is locked in a legal battle over the App Store, and according to a recent report, the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals has ruled that Apple can indeed be sued by those who claim that the company created a monopoly in the app industry by allowing iOS users to only download and install apps from the App Store. This ruling is essentially a reversal of a decision that was made in 2013.

Apple argues that it’s basically just renting out App Store space, so users can’t sue it in the first place — instead, they can sue developers, who are the ones that set the prices for apps.

Recommended Videos

The case itself dates back to 2012, when users sued Apple for allegedly creating a monopoly in the app market by letting users only download apps from the App Store, and thus only allowing users to download apps that Apple had approved. Because the apps are all approved  by Apple, users argued that there was a lack of competition and thus app prices were higher.

The new ruling, however, doesn’t necessarily rule that Apple has indeed created a monopoly — it just rules that users have the right to sue Apple. Now that ruling is out of the way, the original case will go ahead, though there’s no date yet as to when that case will proceed.

So what’s the goal of the case in the first place? According to the Reuters report, the goal is that Apple will open up the app ecosystem, allowing users to download apps from third-party sources, which could ultimately lower the price of apps. It’s also been suggested that a damages payment will be a part of the case.

Christian de Looper
Christian de Looper is a long-time freelance writer who has covered every facet of the consumer tech and electric vehicle…
Apple’s internal tests show Siri isn’t quite ready to beat ChatGPT
Apple Intelligence update on iPhone 15 Pro Max.

With the introduction of the new iPad Mini, Apple made it clear that a software experience brimming with AI is the way forward. And if that meant making the same kind of internal upgrades to a tablet that costs nearly half as much as its flagship phone, the company would still march forward.

However, its ambitions with Apple Intelligence lack competitive vigor, and even by Apple’s own standards, the experience hasn’t managed to wow users. On top of that, the staggered rollout of the most ambitious AI features — many of which are still in the future — has left enthusiasts with a bad impression.

Read more
This is my favorite weather app of 2024
AccuWeather app on iPhone.

We’ve already told you what the best weather apps are this year. After reviewing that list, I was tasked with finding my personal favorite weather app. While this sounds simple enough, it actually isn’t once you decide which features you want beyond the basics, like current and weekly weather information.

There are so many excellent weather apps available in 2024, but after sifting through numerous ones, I've officially settled on my favorite of the year.
Key features to look for in a weather app

Read more
I created the perfect iOS 18 Control Center
Someone holding an iPhone 16, showing the Control Center.

Apple's iOS 18 update is a big one. You can tint and change the colors of your app icons, freely place apps/widgets on your home screen, customize your lock screen controls, and more. There's a lot to dig into.

One of the other big features is the ability to fully customize the Control Center, and admittedly, I've largely ignored it since I downloaded the iOS 18 beta months ago. But last Friday after work, I took some time to dive headfirst into the Control Center on my iPhone 16 and completely rearrange it. After about 30 minutes of tinkering with things, I think I created the perfect Control Center setup.
How I set up my Control Center

Read more