Skip to main content

iMessage: Judge orders Apple to face lawsuit over disappearing text messages

apple imessage facetime patent infringement
If Apple thought that launching a Web tool to clear up an ongoing iMessage issue would finally put the whole thing to bed, it was wrong.

A lawsuit brought against the company back in May that claimed the tech giant failed to explain to iPhone users that text messages would fail to arrive if they switched to a handset with a different operating system was this week given the green light to proceed, Reuters reported Tuesday.

Recommended Videos

US District Court Judge Lucy Koh said in a San Jose, California court that Apple will have to defend itself against the claim brought earlier this year by Adrienne Moore.

The plaintiff had switched from an iPhone 4 to a Galaxy S5, but a failure to deregister her old Apple phone from iMessage meant countless text messages never made it to her new Android handset.

Judge Koh, who’s already well known to Apple through the company’s long-running patent-related battles with Samsung, said Moore should be allowed the opportunity to present her claim that the tech giant interfered with her wireless service contract and broke California’s ‘unfair competition’ law by preventing text messages from reaching her, Reuters reported.

Responding to Moore’s claim in court papers, the Cupertino company said, “Apple takes customer satisfaction extremely seriously, but the law does not provide a remedy when, as here, technology simply does not function as plaintiff subjectively believes it should.”

While Apple acknowledged the existence of the iMessage bug several months ago, it took till this week to roll out an effective fix.

As for how Moore fares in her court battle against one of the biggest companies in the world, we’ll keep you posted.

Trevor Mogg
Contributing Editor
Not so many moons ago, Trevor moved from one tea-loving island nation that drives on the left (Britain) to another (Japan)…
This EU law could force Apple to open up iMessage and the App Store
Someone holding an iPhone 14 with the display turned on.

The EU's Digital Markets Act (or DMA) has gone into force today. It could force Apple to open up the iPhone's iMessage and app-buying platforms to third-party apps and services. Companies that fall afoul of the act could be fined up to 20% of global turnover. Apple has previously criticized the DMA for being a "blunt instrument."

The DMA aims to allow smaller services to compete more equitably with larger ones. This means that companies with a certain number of users, labeled as gatekeepers, would have to make their platforms interoperable with smaller ones. Large platforms like Facebook or iMessage, for example, would be required to open up, while something like Signal could scrape by.

Read more
This sketchy iMessage rumor is the worst thing I’ve seen all year
A concept image render of a new redesigned iMessage app on the iPhone

I’ve used every iPhone, including the original, since 2008, when I received one as a birthday gift. The OG iPhone was my first Apple product, and it kind of got me started down the rabbit hole of all things Apple. I eventually bought a MacBook, iPad, and Apple Watch after my first iPhone.

One of the things that I’ve grown to like about Apple products is their simplicity. Everything is pretty simple to understand, so you can get going on actually using the product. One of those things is iMessage, and I rely on it every single day to stay in touch with my friends and family on my iPhone 14 Pro, iPad Pro, Apple Watch, and iMac.

Read more
How to filter unknown senders in text messages on iOS 16
The iOS 16 logo on an iPhone.

Are you tired of seeing spam texts tangled up with texts from people in your contacts list? Or perhaps you're tired of trying to read a text from someone close to you and seeing a spam text come on top of it in the process. In case you haven't noticed anything else new with iOS 16 in the last day or so, a brand-new feature enables you to separate the two: Filter Unknown Senders.

Read more