Skip to main content

Apple back in the dock after iPod case gets a new plaintiff

iPod Classic
Image used with permission by copyright holder
The ongoing Apple antitrust lawsuit — in which the tech company is accused of squeezing non-iTunes music off its own devices — is back on course again after a new plaintiff was found to represent consumers in the case. Barbara Bennett, a 65 year-old business consultant and amateur figure skater from Massachusetts, stepped forward after reading about the billion-dollar court battle in the news.

The story so far, if you’re just joining us: Apple stands accused of unfairly trying to keep third-party music apps and audio tracks off its iDevices in an attempt to monopolize control over the music market (or as Apple would have it, maintain standards on its hardware). Lawyers are suing Apple on behalf of some 8 million consumers who purchased iPods between 2006 and 2009, but the case has been floundering due to the original plaintiffs being ruled as ineligible.

Recommended Videos

As we reported earlier this month, the final two plaintiffs — representing the estimated 8 million customers in the case — were withdrawn from the suit after it was discovered they hadn’t purchased iPods during the right time period. Presiding district judge Yvonne Gonzalez-Rogers has said she has is satisfied that Barbara Bennett meets the necessary criteria, reports The Stack, and so the legal machinations can continue.

The case is significant because it will set down a marker for the kind of control tech companies are allowed to exert over their own products. Apple has already admitted that it did delete non-iTunes songs from iPods for a period of two years by forcing users to reset their devices if any third-party downloads were detected — however, executives claim it was with device safety and ease-of-use in mind rather than a desire to monopolize the digital music market.

The antitrust lawsuit, which could cost Apple up to $350 million, was originally filed in 2005 but is only now making its way to the final court stages. A recording of a deposition Steve Jobs made in 2011 is expected to be part of the evidence used by lawyers.

Topics
David Nield
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Dave is a freelance journalist from Manchester in the north-west of England. He's been writing about technology since the…
We might know the release day for Apple’s new iPad mini
The iPad Mini and Apple pencil work very well together.

The wait for a new iPad mini is nearly over. According to Bloomberg's Mark Gurman, a next-generation model should be announced and launched in the coming weeks. This will end a long, three-year wait for a fresh iPad mini. Gurman says the seventh-generation iPad mini 7 could ship on Friday, November 1, after an announcement toward the end of this month.

Little is known about the new iPad mini, although we can probably make some educated guesses. The device will most likely feature an Apple M2 chip, the same one found in the iPad Air (2024). The new tablet could also come with a 12MP ultrawide camera in landscape orientation, provide support for the Apple Pencil Pro, and bring various other improvements.

Read more
Next year’s iPhone could get a surprise new button
iPhone 16 Pro Max in Desert Titanium.

This might sound funny, but it seems the biggest hardware updates for iPhones are reserved for the buttons. After adding an Action Button on the iPhone 15 Pro, and then adding a Camera Control shutter across the iPhone 16 series, it seems the iPhone 17 Pro will introduce yet another take on a button.

As reliable leaker Majin Bu reports, Apple is reportedly testing “a new button that will replace the volume buttons and the Action Button that have been removed” on its next flagship.

Read more
The best Apple iPhone 16 Pro cases for 2024
Someone holding the iPhone 16 Pro.

Apple has officially released the iPhone 16 and its variations, including the Apple iPhone 16 Pro. Apple's It's Glowtime event revealed the upgrades to the phone, including better screen protection, camera features, and AI integration. Under the hood, the iPhone 16 Pro also boasts an even stronger CPU, with increased memory bandwidth and improved performance. If you've decided that the iPhone 16 Pro is your next buy, you should also get a case to keep it safe.

There are many kinds of cases out there to suit every style or preference. Here are some of our favorites.

Read more