Skip to main content

Nokia defeats Apple in patent battle

nokia-apple-elop-jobs-2
Nokia has crushed Apple‘s legal warriors in a patent dispute that has the iPhone maker coughing up a one-time settlement and ongoing licensing fees, announced Nokia in a press release today. The agreement between the two companies is the conclusion of a two-year standoff widely seen as the most significant patent battle in an industry rife with intellectual property disputes.

While the exact terms of the agreement are strictly confidential, Nokia says that the licensing agreement is “signed,” which “will result in settlement of all patent litigation between the companies, including the withdrawal by Nokia and Apple of their respective complaints to the US International Trade Commission,” the press release reads.

Recommended Videos

The fight between Finland-based Nokia and Cupertino, California-based Apple began in October 2009, when Nokia filed its first patent claim against Apple. The dispute included demands by Nokia that Apple pay royalties on all iPhone devices sold. Eventually, Nokia had a total of 46 patent claims against Apple. In turn, Apple filed its own patent infringement claims against Nokia.

“We are very pleased to have Apple join the growing number of Nokia licensees,” said Nokia President and CEO Stephen Elop in a prepared statement. “This settlement demonstrates Nokia’s industry leading patent portfolio and enables us to focus on further licensing opportunities in the mobile communications market.”

The settlement is big for two primary reasons: First, it shows that its possible to beat Apple at a game for which it is fiercely competitive. Second, the agreement proves the strength of Nokia’s patent portfolio.

Because of this, the company’s stock jumped 3 percent in the Helsinki, Finland stock market. And Nokia will be able to revise its second quarter 2011 outlook, which brings the company’s operating margin back up to break-even numbers.

Topics
Andrew Couts
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Features Editor for Digital Trends, Andrew Couts covers a wide swath of consumer technology topics, with particular focus on…
Apple Fitness+ vs. Peloton: Can Apple’s new fitness service defeat the champ?
Apple Fitness Plus

During Apple's iPad and Apple Watch event on Tuesday, the company announced a new service coming to its suite of offerings -- Apple Fitness+. In short, Fitness+ is a workout service that integrates the Workouts app in your Apple Watch directly with an on-screen guided workout session on your iPhone, iPad, or Apple TV. Aside from the integration with the Apple Watch, that sounds a lot like what Peloton has spent years building.

With Fitness+ arriving as the only real competitor to Peloton, how do the two services stack up?

Read more
Apple ordered to pay over $500 million in fines for violating LTE patents
apple iphone xr and xs amazon deals review 5 768x479 c

Apple has been fined $506 million by a federal jury in Texas for “willfully” infringing a total of five patents on cellular standards. The lawsuit was filed by a group of companies including PanOptics and Optis Wireless Technology over a year ago; it claimed Apple owed them royalties for violating several patents on LTE technology.

The court concluded Apple’s arguments were insufficient and that the infringement was willful, according to a Bloomberg report, which means the fine’s amount could be upped by as much as threefold later.

Read more
Apple explores how to create a group selfie when no one’s nearby
disney bans selfie sticks from its theme parks stick

Apple has just been granted a patent outlining an idea for creating group selfies without everyone having to crowd around a single camera to get the shot.

The tech giant calls the feature a “synthetic group selfie” that would be created automatically on an iPhone or iPad using single-person selfies submitted by those who want to appear in the group picture.

Read more