Skip to main content

Want to make money? Study says Instagram beats Twitter, Facebook in brand engagement

instagram photos not showing up anymore in twitter how s 1 billion sale helps other photo sharing startups ab5366e4e8
Where can brands get the best results promoting themselves online? Twitter is receiving hype as an advertising tool, but according to a new study, Instagram beats out its competitors as the social media destination most effective at turning digital ‘likes’ into cold, hard cash.

Business analytics firm SumAll looked at brand performance on Instagram, Twitter, Facebook, and Google+, and issued a verdict in no uncertain terms: “On this day, Instagram has been appointed supreme ruler of the social media universe,” the company’s blog proclaims. SumAll looked at data from 6,000 customers and Screen Shot 2013-12-09 at 9.32.08 AMdetermined that Instagram gives businesses far superior returns on investments than other social networks. In the U.S., Instagram drove revenue up between 1.5-3 percent, and the photo-sharing app produced even larger gains in the U.K.

While SumAll appears to be the first analytics firm boldly coronating Instagram for its branding superiority, a study by SimplyMeasured highlighted how swiftly brand engagement grew on the photo-sharing site in 2013. SimplyMeasured found a 350-percent increase in brand engagement among ‘top brands’ over the past year. And it appears these brands are engaging with purpose, since active Instagram use bolsters revenue. SimplyMeasured echoes SumAll in its recommendation of Instagram over other platforms. “There’s been less resistance to the addition than other networks have seen, suggesting that users are more comfortable with branded content when it’s visually appealing,” the study notes.

Although SumAll emphasized that Instagram handily bested its competition, it warned of posting too frequently, noting “being too active on a single network can lead to diminishing returns so experiment as much as possible.” In other words, don’t be overzealous.

Instagram privileges images, and people tend to be less grumpy and more interested in ads and promoted content when it looks good, so brands capable of producing attractive images and videos have a good chance of getting positive feedback on the network. Instagram’s current advertising strategy doesn’t disrupt the pleasure of looking at its clean-cut stream of images, so promoted content and media posted by brands appears as a native element of the platform – something parent company Facebook and rival Twitter have struggled to achieve.

Kate Knibbs
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Kate Knibbs is a writer from Chicago. She is very happy that her borderline-unhealthy Internet habits are rewarded with a…
Twitter CEO claims platform had best day last week
A stylized composite of the Twitter logo.

Twitter CEO Linda Yaccarino tweeted on Monday that despite the current fuss over Meta’s new and very similar Threads app, Twitter had its largest usage day last week.

Subtly including the name of Meta’s new app, which launched to great fanfare last Wednesday, Yaccarino did her best to sing Twitter’s praises, tweeting: “Don’t want to leave you hanging by a thread … but Twitter, you really outdid yourselves! Last week we had our largest usage day since February. There’s only ONE Twitter. You know it. I know it.”

Read more
Meta brings cartoon avatars to video calls on Instagram and Messenger
Meta's cartoon avatars for Instagram and Messenger.

The pandemic was supposed to have made us all comfortable with video calls, but many folks still don’t particularly enjoy the process.

Having to think about what to wear, or how our hair looks, or even fretting about puffy eyes following another bout of hay fever can sometimes be a bit much, even more so if it’s an early-morning call and your brain is still in bed.

Read more
Twitter is now giving money to some of its creators
A lot of white Twitter logos against a blue background.

Some Twitter users are now earning money via ads in the replies to their tweets.

New Twitter owner Elon Musk announced the revenue-sharing program in February, and on Thursday some of those involved have been sharing details of their first payments.

Read more